Do you feel personal control contributes most to your health and well-being?
How does relational strain come into play?
To investigate the relationship between culture and well-being, a cross-cultural survey was conducted, focusing on two hypotheses and the two very different cultures of Japan and America.
The Hypotheses
The first hypothesis suggests that individuals are influenced by the predominant cultural norms of either independence (emphasizing personal control) in the United States or interdependence (emphasizing relational harmony) in Japan.
The second hypothesis proposes that individuals attain well-being and health by aligning with the cultural mandates of their respective societies.
Ethnocentricity & Previous Studies
Previous studies, predominantly conducted in North America, have consistently found that personal control and mastery are strong predictors of well-being and health (Lachman and Weaver, 1998; Schneiderman et al., 2001).
However, this may be a somewhat ethnocentric view.
The present research, utilizing diverse age groups from both the United States and Japan, reveals that the impact of these factors is contingent on cultural context.
While biological factors certainly play a role in health, this survey highlights the significant influence of culture-specific psychological variables, such as personal control and relational harmony or strain, on various health outcomes.
The Results
Consistent with the first hypothesis, it was found that Americans who felt their personal control was compromised and Japanese individuals experiencing strained relationships reported higher levels of perceived constraint.
As expected, the study revealed that the strongest predictor of well-being and health in the United States was personal control, whereas in Japan, the absence of relational strain played a significant role.
The data revealed relatively small but statistically significant effects of relational harmony or relational strain on wellbeing and health among Americans.
The overall results highlight the existence of culturally distinct pathways to achieving positive life outcomes.
In the United States, personal control emerges as a crucial factor, whereas in Japan, the absence of relational strain is key.
These findings underscore the influence of cultural values on individual well-being and emphasize the importance of understanding cultural nuances when studying and promoting positive life outcomes.